
Skorzeny [ Centurion ]
Forum CM: Rozpoznanie bojem (zwiad bojem)...
lub combat reconnaissance albo reconnaissance in force. No właśnie, ten wątek kieruję zwłaszcza do naszych sławnych teoretyków wojny.
1. Na czym konkretnie polega, czy ktoś zna jakąś w miarę precyzyjną definicję takiego manewru, o ile takowa istnieje? Ogólnie można oczywiście powiedzieć, że chodzi o wybadanie pozycji przeciwnika i jego sił, jak to jednak ma się do praktyki prowadzenia działań?
2. Czy zwiad bojowy był częstym manewrem w historii wojen? O ile mi wiadomo, a jestem raczej laikiem, Patton często nadużywał tego manewru jako pretekstu do zaatakowania pozycjii wroga na pełną skalę (np. pod Akwizgranem).
3. Czym różni się zwiad od rozpoznania bojem? Z mojej wiedzy wynika że dowódcy często dosyć dowolnie interpretowali znaczenie tego manewru, ponieważ jest bardzo nieprecyzyjny
jiser [ generał-major Zajcef ]
Wiem, że nieuprzejmie jest cytować duże ilości tekstów, w dodatku w języku obcym, ale nie mam teraz ani czasu ani sił na tłumaczenie. Poniżej tekst jak w marcu '45 wojskowe służby informacyjne charakteryzowały niemiecką taktykę w zakresie rozpoznania.
jiser [ generał-major Zajcef ]
****************************
Section II. RECONNAISSANCE
****************************
a: PURPOSE.
The purpose of reconnaissance and they types of units employed to obtain information are similar in the U.S. and the German Armies. German tactical principles of reconnaissance, however, diverge somewhat from those of the U.S. The Germans stress aggressiveness, attempt to obtain superiority in the area to be reconnoitered, and strive for continuous observation of the enemy. They believe in employing reconnaissance units in force as a rule. They expect
and are prepared to fight to obtain the desired information. Often they assign supplementary tasks to their reconnaissance units, such as sabotage behind enemy lines, harassment, or counter-reconnaissance.
b. TECHNIQUE.
Only enough reconnaissance troops are sent on a mission to assure superiority in the area to be reconnoitered. Reserves are kept on hand to be committed when the reconnaissance must be intensified, when the original force meets strong enemy opposition, or when the direction and area to be reconnoitered are changed. The Germans encourage aggressive action against enemy security
forces. When their reconaissance units meet superior forces, they fight a delaying action while other units attempt to flank the enemy.
c. CLASSIFICATION.
Reconnaissance is classified by the Germans as operational, tactical, and battle reconaissance - corresponding to the U.S. Distant, close, and battle reconnaissance.
2. OPERATIONAL RECONNAISSANCE (Operative Aufklarung)
Operational reconnaissance, penetrating over a large area in great depth, provides the basis for strategic planning and action. This type of reconnaissance is intended to determine the location and activities of enemy forces, particularly localities of rail concentrations, forward or rearward
displacements of personnel, loading or unloading areas of army elements, the construction of field or permanent fortifications, and hostile air force concentrations. Identification of large enemy motorized elements, especially
on an open flank, is important. Operational reconnaissance is carried out by the Air Force and by motorized units. Aerial photography units operate at altitudes of 16,500 to 26,500 feet. Since missions assigned to operational air reconnaissance are generally limited to the observation of important roads
and railroads, reconnaissance sectors and areas normally are not assigned. The motorized units employed for operational reconnaissance have only directions and
objectives assigned.
3. TACTICAL RECONNAISSANCE (Taktische Aufklarung)
a. PURPOSE
Tactical reconnaissance, carried out in the area behind the operational reconnaissance, provides the basis for the commitment of troops. Its mission embraces identification of the enemy's organization, disposition, strength, and antiaircraft defense; determination of the enemy's reinforcement capabilities; and terrain reconnaissance of advance sectors. Air Force reconnaissance units and motorized and mounted reconnaissance battalions are employed for tactical reconnaissance. Their direction and radius of employment are based upon the results of the operational reconnaissance.
b. AIR RECONNAISSANCE.
Tactical air reconnaissance is normally made from altitudes of 6,500 to 16,000 feet. As a rule, air reconnaissance units are assigned specific reconnaissance areas, the boundaries of which normally do not coincide with sectors assigned to
ground units. Reconnaissance planes generally are employed singly.
c. GROUND RECONNAISSANCE.
Sectors of responsibility are assigned to ground tactical reconnaissance battalions. In order to make them independent or to facilitate their change of direction, battalions may be assigned only reconnaissance objectives. In such instances, boundary lines separate adjacent units. The Germans avoid
using main roads as boundary lines, defining the sectors in such a way that main roads fall within the reconnaissance sectors. The width of a sector is determined by the situation, the type and strength of the reconnaissance battalion, the road net, and the terrain. In general, the width of a
sector assigned to a motorized reconnaissance batalion does not exceed 30 miles.
d. ORDERS FOR TACTICAL RECONNAISSANCE.
Orders issued to a reconnaissance battalion or it's patrols normally contain, in addition to the mission, the following:
(1) Line of departure
(2) Information concerning adjacent reconnaissance units
(3) Sector boundaries or direction of operation.
(4) Objectives.
(5) Phase lines.
(6) Instructions for transmission of reports.
(7) Location of immediate objectives whose attainment is to
be reported.
(8) Instructions regarding air-ground liaison.
(9) Time of departure, route, and objective of the main force.
e. TACTICAL RECONNAISSANCE PROCEDURES.
When a motorized reconnaissance column expects contact with the enemy, it advances by leaps and bounds. The length of bounds depends on the cover the terrain offers as well as on the road net. As the distance from the enemy decreases, the bounds are shortened. The Germans utilize roads as long as possible and usually use different routes for the advance and the return.
The reconnaissance battalion commander normally sends out patrols which advance by bounds. Their distance in front of the battalion depends on the situation, the terrain, and the range of the signal equipment, but as a rule they are not more than an hour's travelling distance (about 25 miles)
ahead of the battalion. The battalion serves as the reserve for the patrols and as an advance message center (Meldekopf), collecting the messages and relaying them to the rear. Armored reconnaissance cars, armored half-tracks, or
motorcycles compose the motorized reconnaissance patrols, whose exact composition depends on their mission and on the situation. Motorcycles are used to fill in gaps and intervals, thereby thickening the reconnaissance net.
When the proximity of the enemy does not permit profitable employment of the motorized reconnaissance battalion, it is withdrawn and the motorized elements of the divisional reconnaissance battalion take over.
Divisional reconnaissance battalions seldom operate more than one day's march (18 miles) in front of the division, covering an area approximately 6 miles wide.
4. BATTLE RECONNAISSANCE. (Gefechtsaufklarung)
a. GENERAL
Battle reconnaissance as a rule is begun when the opposing forces begin to deploy. All troops participating in battle carry out battle reconnaissance through patrols, artillery observation posts, observation battalions, and air
reconnaissance units. The information obtained on the organization and strength of the enemy provides the basis for the conduct of the battle.
b. ARMORED CAR PATROLS.
The Panzer division dispatches armored reconnaissance units equipped with armored vehicles and numerous automatic weapons. The armored reconnaissance unit is fast and has a wide radius of action.
Armored car patrols normally are composed of three armored reconnaissance cars, one of which is equipped with radio. An artillery observer often accompanies the patrol so that in an emergency fire can be brought down quickly. This type of patrol usually is organized for missions lasting one to two
days. Tasks are defined clearly, and nothing is allowed to interfere with the patrols's main objective. If enemy forces are met, action is avoided unless the force is so weak that it can be destroyed without diverting the patrol from it's
main task. If enemy action is anticipated, the patrol is reinforced with self-propelled guns and occasionally with tanks. Engineers and motorcyclists are often attached to the patrol to deal with road blocks and demolitions.
While scouting a woods, a favorite German ruse is to drive the leading car towards it's edge, halt briefly to observe, and then drive off rapidly, hoping to draw enemy fire that will disclose the enemy positions.
At road blocks, the leading car opens fire. If fire is not returned, men dismount and go forward to attach tow ropes to the road block. If necessary, the patrol dismounts and proceeds with machine guns to reconnoiter on foot.
A patrol is never split up, but in open country distances between cars may be as much as 200 to 300 yards.
c. OBSERVATION BATTALION AND AIR RECONNAISSANCE.
The German observation battalion locates enemy artillery and heavy weapons positions by sound and flash ranging and evaluated aerial photographs. The Air Force assists in battalion reconnaissance by observing the distribution of
the enemy's forces, his artillery, bivouac and movements, reserves, tank assemblies, and any other special occurences behind the front. In general, air battle reconnaissance is executed under 6,000 feet.
d. BATTLE RECONNAISSANCE PATROLS (Spahtruppen)
The Germans send out reconnaissance patrols consisting of a noncommissioned officer and three or four men, to get such information as the location of enemy positions and minefields. They generally avoid contact and retreat when fired on.
e. COMBAT PATROLS (Gefechtsspahtruppen or Strosstruppen)
These consist of at least one noncommissioned officer and eight men, but are usually stronger. As a rule, the combat patrol is commanded by a sergeant who has under him 15 to 20 men, organized in two equal sections, each commanded by a
section leader. These are raiding patrols, and their mission often includes bringing back prisoners of war. Since Allied air supremacy has neutralized German air reconnaissance to a great extent, the Germans have placed increased importance on prisoners of war, especially officers, as a source of
information on enemy strength, dispositions, and intentions.
Combat or other types of patrols are often sent out to test the strength of enemy outposts. If an outpost proves to be weakly held, the patrol attacks, occupies the position, and remains there until relieved by troops from the rear. If the patrol is strongly garrisoned, the patrol attempts to return with a prisoner of war.
f. SPECIAL PATROLS (Spahtruppen mit besonderen Aufgaben)
These vary in strength in accordance with their special mission. Special patrols are sent to carry out such tasks as demolitions, engaging of enemy patrols that have penetrated German positions, and ambushing enemy supply columns.
g. MISCELLANEOUS RECONNAISSANCE.
Engineer patrols are employed to reconnoiter approaches to fortified areas, defiles, or rivers. Artillery patrols, usually consisting of an officer and a few mounted men, reconnoiter routes of approach, observation posts, and firing positions.
h. TERRAIN RECONNAISSANCE. (Gelandeerkundung)
The Germans place great emphasis on terrain reconnaissance, realizing the influence terrain has upon the conduct of operations. Most of their usual reconnaissance missions include terrain reconnaissance tasks. Terrain may be so
important at times as to require reconnaissance by special units. Ground and air reconnaissance units give special attention to the road net - its density, condition, road blocks, mines, and demolitions - as well to the terrain itself,
particularly tank country.
i. EQUIPMENT AND SUPPORT.
The Germans equip their ground battle-reconnaissance patrols with machine pistols and one or two light machine guns that are used to cover the patrol's approach or withdrawal. Engineers often are attached to guide a patrol through German minefields and to clear a way through enemy wire or mines. Artillery support is given in the form of harassing fire put down just before the patrol reaches its objective. Sometimes the artillery fires into adjacent sectors to
mislead the enemy as to the actual area to be reconnoitered. In other instances, artillery and mortars that have registered during the previous day shell during the night the area to be reconnoitered. As soon as the barrage is lifted, the patrol advances under cover of machine-gun fire from flanking positions.

traun [ Pretorianin ]
Witam kolegę! Dla tych co nieznają angielskiego polecam link poniżej ale opis jest dość mętny
...mnie osobiście "rozpoznanie bojem" to ładna taktyka radziecka posyłania żołnierzy bez rozpoznania a jak dostali w pierdziel to się posyłałao więcej.....
ssjNaza [ Pretorianin ]
Wiem tyle, że istniało coś takiego jak rozpoznanie ogniem. Stosowano w Vietnamie, strzelali w las i czekali czy las odpowie tym samym :)
A jeśli chodzi o rozpoznanie bojem to wydaje mi się, że jest to jakiegoś typu pozoracja natarcia. Atakują, wciągają siły nieprzyjaciela w walkę i następnie wycofują się, albo ściągają posiłki wiedząc już czym dysponuje npl.
Kłosiu [ Senator ]
W skrocie, tak jak ja to rozumiem, rozpoznanie bojem polegalo na tym, ze wysylano jednostke (pluton, kompanie, batalion - zalezy od poziomu operacyjnego), ktora nawiazywala kontakt bojowy z nplem i walczyla jakis czas, identyfikujac gniazda oporu, stanowiska ckmow, dziala itp. a potem sie wycofywala. W ten sposob jednostki atakujace jako nastepne mialy dokladnie rozpoznany system obrony npla.
Praktyka stosowana niezwykle czesto i przez wszystkie armie biorace udzial w wojnie.
Skorzeny [ Centurion ]
Dziekuje wszystkim, dokładnie tak to sobie wybrażam jak Kłosiu. Wygląda więc na to że nie ma ścisłej definicji takiego manewru

mgk [ Generał - Pacyfista ]
A tak to wygląda w praktyce :-)

Skorzeny [ Centurion ]
mgk ---> lol, tak to chyba wygląda radziecki karny batalion po rozminowaniu pola :D
CATAN [ Pretorianin ]
haha ale bokiem, bokiem i laskiem, laksiem:)))
rozpoznanie bojem to podstawa: przy wszytskich większych związkach taktycznych tylko w ten sposób można stwierdzić o sile npla. I podjąć decyzje, czy maszerująca np brygada ma się rozwinąć do uderzenia, czy może maszerować dalej a awangarda poradzi sobie ze spotkanym wrogiem. W CM czasami lepiej pasuje sformułowanie "wabik" :))
mgk [ Generał - Pacyfista ]
No coż - moi niemieszkowie siedzieli cicho i jak już ruscy podeszli naprawde blisko to się zaczeło :-) - ale jeden uciekl :-))

Michael_wittmann [ Konsul ]
U mnie na uczelni rozpoznanie bojem (taktyka używana przez około 10-20 % studentów) polega na pójścu na egzamin kompletnie nieprzygotowanym (ew. jakieś małe ściągawki) no i spisaniu pytań ewentualnie pilnym rozglądaniem się po kolegach, gdyż statystycznie ok. 30-40 % pytań powtarza się, na drugim terminie
pozdrawiam

clown10 [ Pretorianin ]
michael wittmann---->jakbym stosował twoją metodę na mojej uczelni to nawet semestru bym nie zdał :-p

mardel [ Chor��y ]
mgk --> czy to są moi dzielni wojacy w Twojej zasadzce? :D
Rozpoznanie bojem - ruska taktyka. Polega na wysłaniu karnego plutonu/kompani na silnie umocnione pozycje niemców np. w miasteczku. Niemcy strzelają a dowwóca ruskich patrzy przez lornetkę z którego okna strzela MG42, na jakiej uliczce stoi PAK i gdzie ukryte są czołgi. Nastęnie sciąga się katisze i strzela w te miejsca no i kompletuje nowy pluton karny :D
wittman, clown --> a na mojej uczelni stosuje tę taktykę na każdym egzaminie i zawsze wychodzi. Ale najlepsze jest to że nie potrzebuję już 2 terminu. :D
mgk [ Generał - Pacyfista ]
Mardel - a jak poznales ;-))
Ja jestem w bojach uczelnianych po drugiej stronie frontu i to ja urządzam zasadzki - czasami takie jak ta w ktorą wpadl Mardel ;-))
snekkar [ Chor��y ]
W bitwie pod Lenino właśnie zastosowano rozpoz. walka w sile batalionu w celu określenia
Siły obsadzających pierwsza linie i rozpoznania artylerii na tyłach, bo Niemcy często pierwsza linie obsadzali ubezpieczeniami a główna linie większością sił i jeśli ruski się nie połapali to zaczynając natarcie artyleria wywalała większość na tych nielicznych z ubezpieczenia nie niszcząc głównych sił i w przypadku natarcia piechoty obrona nie była ruszona i zwykle skoczyło się to rzezią atakujących. Co do Polaków to Niemcy nie zostawili ubezpieczeń tylko obsadzili od razu pierwsza linie głównie, dlatego ze przed ich liniami
był bagnisty teren i ich atak zakończył się krwawa łaźnia a ich informacje zdobyte w walce wskutek skrócenia przez ruskiego dowódcę ognia artyleryjskiego tez do końca nie wykorzystano i bitwa w sumie skończyła się niewielkim sukcesem i gigantycznymi stratami –taki mi się przypomniał epizod z historii na ten temat
Skorzeny [ Centurion ]
ufff... aleś to jednym tchem wyłożył... ale w sumie ciekawa informacja